An identity theft case is rarely one problem. It's a dozen: a fraudulent credit card, a loan nobody applied for, a phone account in the victim's name, a tax return filed by someone else, collection calls for debts they never owed. Each one has its own company to contact, its own paperwork and its own clock. Recovery firms that track all of that in spreadsheets and email end up asking the victim, "Where are we on the auto loan?" when it should be the other way around.
This guide covers what an identity theft recovery firm should track, how to structure a case so no account is forgotten, and what to automate.
This article is general information, not legal advice.
Structure each case around affected accounts
The case is the client's whole situation. The affected accounts are the individual pieces of work. Treat each as its own record, linked to the case, with:
- Institution and account type (credit card, loan, utility, phone, bank, tax, medical, government benefit)
- What happened: new account opened, existing account taken over, fraudulent charges, debt in collection
- Status: identified, disputed, documentation sent, awaiting response, resolved, escalated
- Dates: when you contacted them, when a response is due, when it was resolved
- Owner: the specialist working it
A case is closed when every affected account is resolved, and not before. That's the whole point of tracking them one by one.
The standard recovery steps
Most cases share a core set of steps, and each one is worth tracking on the case with a date:
- Identity theft report. In the US, filing at IdentityTheft.gov creates an FTC Identity Theft Report and a personal recovery plan. Many of the steps below rely on it.
- Fraud alerts. A fraud alert placed with one of the three credit bureaus is passed to the other two. An initial alert lasts one year; with an identity theft report, the victim can get an extended alert that lasts seven years.
- Credit freezes. Free at each of the three bureaus, and the strongest block on new accounts. Each bureau has to be contacted separately.
- Blocking fraudulent information. With an identity theft report, the Fair Credit Reporting Act lets the victim ask the credit bureaus to block fraudulent information from their report. The bureaus generally must act within four business days.
- Disputes with each company where an account was opened or misused.
Track which of these is done for each client, with dates, so you can see at a glance which cases are missing a step.
What else to track
- Intake details: how the theft was discovered, police report number if there is one, and the documents collected
- Every contact with the client and with institutions, on the case timeline
- Documents sent and received: affidavits, reports, letters, and their dates
- Sensitive identifiers, encrypted and visible only to the people working the case
Automate these first
- Response deadlines. When an affected account is disputed, create a follow-up task for its response date.
- Overdue accounts. Flag affected accounts with no update in 14 days.
- Client updates. A templated email whenever an affected account is resolved, so the victim sees progress.
- Extended alert and freeze reminders. Tasks ahead of fraud alert expirations, and a reminder for clients to keep their freezes in place.
- Intake to case. When a lead signs up, open the case with your standard checklist of steps.
Reports to watch
- Open cases by specialist, with the number of unresolved affected accounts
- Affected accounts by status and institution type, to see where cases get stuck
- Average time to resolve an affected account, by institution type
- Cases missing a core step, such as no fraud alert or freeze recorded
- New clients by source, for your intake pipeline and partners
Protect the data you hold
Recovery firms hold exactly the information identity thieves want. Encrypt sensitive fields, limit who can see which cases, require two-step sign-in, and keep an audit trail of who viewed and changed what.
How Colurian handles it
Colurian ships an ID Shield edition you switch on from Setup. It adds Identity Theft Cases and Affected Accounts, and an Identity Theft Case field on tasks and events, so every call and follow-up lands on the right case. Opportunities and campaigns stay for intake and lead generation, while products, quotes and price books are hidden.
Underneath is the full CRM: encrypted sensitive fields, field-level security, sharing rules, two-step sign-in, flows for the automations above, and reports and dashboards, at $39 per user per month.
Book a 30-minute demo and we'll walk through a case from intake to the last resolved account.
